I Like Pie Bakeshop - Pasadena, California

Florian B.

I visit "I Like Pie" in Pasadena quite often, and it’s one of my top favorite places in the area. I’ve consistently had positive experiences. The pastries are always well-presented and of excellent quality, and the variety ensures there’s something for everyone to enjoy. The location is convenient, and their hours are ideal for stopping by at any time during the day (closed Mon-Tue).

I especially love the service—staff members are consistently professional and attentive, with a special mention to Ashlyn, the manager, whose exceptional approach to customer care is greatly appreciated.

For anyone in Pasadena looking for a reliable bakery with great service, "I Like Pie" is certainly worth a visit!

M S

I live in San Diego , needed to visit Pasadena on Saturday. Found a place has good reviews at Vietnamese restaurant for lunch and I parked in front of this cute pie place and thought I should try this cute pie place after lunch. Got key lime pie and it was so good ❣️❤️?

Benjamin Franke (Solstice Son)

I might cry… I just had pie. It’s hard you see, to find crust free… of gluten but still light, crispy. But look no more, for you have scored. They’ve mastered it, like, oh my lord… Let all your doubts slip away and die. Now taste anything here and shout “I LIKE PIE”

Key lime was my fave.

Candie S Brown

The CUTEST little pie shop in Old Town! I love their individual pies. They're perfectly packaged with so much flavor.

They have so many options. From savory to vegan friendly. My favorites are the classics: key lime, apple and chocolate.

They are a bit pricey, but you are paying for quality ingredients. 3 pies for around $26.

I usually just pick up a couple when I'm running errands, but they'd be a great party favor to bring to your next get together!

Tristan & Ashley Boyd

? Fantastic customer service - staff were knowledgeable and happy to guide us through the various pie choices.

? Located in a great spot, the restaurant’s setting complements the charming vibe of old town Pasadena.

? The interior of I Like Pie creates an upscale ambiance, making it a delightful place to enjoy a sweet treat.

? For those who love unique pie recipes, this is a paradise!

? 5-Star Minis:
Mixed Berry: A perfect balance of sweet and tart. ?

Key Lime: Classic, with a tart and wonderfully creamy texture. ?

Caramel Apple: A delightful twist on apple pie, topped with a dollop of caramel. ?

? 4-Star Treats:
Butter Pecan Mini: Lovely almond and pecan flavors, though it missed the mark on the butter pecan taste. ?

Cherry Hand Pie: The crust was flaky and delightful, but the cherry filling was more of a sugary purée than expected. ?

Overall, I Like Pie serves up deliciously crafted pies in a cozy, upscale setting, making it a must-visit for dessert lovers.

Tim Kerr

We ordered some gluten free pies and jelly jars for thanskgiving and everything tasted fantastic: high quality ingredients, not too sweet, not too heavy, really good gluten free crust. After picking up the pies and driving home, we opened them up and realized the pumpkin pie and one of the jelly jars weren't gluten free (simple mistake on one of the busiest days of the year for them). After calling the store they had us send a couple pictures of the pies to verify they were incorrect. They then proceeded TO DRIVE OVER 30 MILES AT 9PM THE DAY BEFORE THANKSGIVING TO REPLACE THEM. We were shocked by the generosity and told them not to trouble themselves but they were insistent on rectifying the situation. Absolutely phenomenal customer service, can't rate them highly enough. Please support this amazing business!

Kris McCutcheon

I was walking through Pasadena and stumbled across I Like Pie Bakeshop ♡ walked in to see so many amazing ? ? ? ? options. The young ladies behind the counter were both friendly & very helpful. I sat down in a pretty atmosphere and enjoy my pie. Check this little gym of a pie place ♡

Esteban Arenas

I love this place so much.
I accidentally came across it and fell in love. Their pies are so good for a nice sweet craving and offer ice cream as well to pair with them or a shake that’s mixed with a pie of your choice.
I highly recommend to try any of their chocolate flavors.
The staff is caring and kind and love the look of the shop.