Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings I - Mesa, Arizona

Cory Lynch

Yes, I've tried the food. It's greasy and stale. But my main complaint is the time it takes. 15 minutes slowly turns into 30. It's one worker and he refuses to hire more help. He's rude and not sanitary. If you want to door dash this, just don't! Pictured are orders that need to be made and he was sitting in the back. The last one is his bare hands with food over a trashcan.

Kiel Cashman

Ordered an 8 piece boneless garlic parm and 6 piece garlic knot. Received 7 pieces essentially the size of chicken nuggets. Also only received 5 garlic knots instead of 6. Small portion or chicken. Don't get me wrong tbe food is great. But you should get what you pay for.

Lisa Gilbert

Ordered thru GrubHub.. pizza Wow! Best ingredients got Mamas garlic oil jalapeños and black olives. ♥️ As for anti pasta salad, needs some work but ingredients and creamy Italian dressing on point. If new owner would freshen up view from counter, even better.

Sienna Villalobos

Since Little Ceasars never wants my buisness I decided to give the place nextdoor at the Chevron a try and let me tell you it's 10x's better overall! Meat Lovers Pizza will change a Vegans mind js lol. I personally never was a meat lovers fan till ive come here! Ive been coming here for a while now and the staff are always super friendly, great recommendations and nice variety. The pizza is always fresh with fresh ingredients and you're able to watch your food be made! Great Experience, Great Taste definitely recommend. Also gives you a chance to get what you need at the gas station super convenient!

Shawn H

After three different people recommended this place, we decided to check it out last night. As a rule, I don’t eat anything from a gas station. However, I respected the opinion of the New Yorkers who told me I would not be disappointed. Their sauce, dough, and cheese are top shelf. This tastes exactly like a place I love in Manhattan. The customer service was phenomenal. Even though we live 12 freeway minutes away, we will be back weekly. My kids absolutely loved it as well.

Troy

Im looking for a decent pizza shop with pizza similar to my hometown NY. Never been here but I read a review saying a customer was tired of Little Ceasars and tried this. Slightly better customer said! I won't be wasting my time trying anything on the menu.

Tony C

READ UPDATE BELOW:
I’ve been wanting a good New York pie for awhile now but the options are pretty limited by me. Venezia’s was usually the go to spot but I don’t feel that they are authentic New York style. I found this spot on Google while looking for pizza around me. This location is in the chevron so I was a bit hesitant to order because I didn’t want gas station pizza. I read all the positive reviews and looked at the photos to make a call to order. Honestly I’m glad I did! They have a full on pizza kitchen inside the store so it’s not just a gas station pizza like QT. I got a basic cheese pie and it was just as I expected it to be and was just like New York. Super happy I found this spot and will be coming back often. Also they have a drive thru which I didn’t utilize but will be super convenient to pick up pizzas.

UPDATE: Went back again today and pizza was even better than the first time! I’ll be a dedicated customer now. 🙂

UPDATE 12/22: Appears to be completely different staff now. Pizza definitely isn’t as good as it used to be, staff isn’t as friendly anymore. It’s a real shame because this was my go to spot. Now time to find another. May give this spot another chance but the last three times I went it was not worth it. Idk what happened to the big bald guy that used to work there but he would kill it!

Update: 3/15/23 and 3/26/23
Gave this spot a shot again two more times. On 3/15 it was pretty decent but definitely not like it used to be. On 3/26 it was completely different tasting and made me sick to my stomach. What a shame. This used to be one of the better pizza spots in east Mesa and now with people that used to be there not there anymore, it’s god awful. Will not be back again

Adam F

We discovered this gem by chance. If you love hole in the wall mom and pop place this one may be for you. Pizza was actually cheesy(streches before breaking) something I haven't experienced since I was a kid. The pepperoni was delicious and didn't shrink like others do. My daugher had 4 big slices and she never eats pizza. My wife loves the fact that the grease drips off the cheese.

Owner was nice and even asked how I wanted my pizzas cut. The place could use some updating and being a little less cluttered. Also the oven may need to be calibrated a bit as others have said it can be a little soft. Prices are reasonable in comparison to other chains and very filling. I hope others give this place a try. Note if you arrive and don't see anyone just ring the bell.